Sunday, October 11, 2020

The Potomac River May Run Out of Water

 This is a summary of the ICPRB report published September 2020:

The Washington, DC, metropolitan area (WMA) with over three million workers many of whom serve or support the federal government  is also home to almost five million residents. The region’s water suppliers have an important responsibility beyond supplying the needs or the residents: to provide 24/7 water that ensures the federal government, including Congress, the Pentagon, and key agencies can function.  

The water suppliers share the Potomac River as the major regional water resource, and so 35 years ago and came together to form the Interstate Commission on the Potomac River Basin (ICPRB) and a cooperative agreement (Co-Op)  of funding and using the water resources available regionally. One of the requirements of the agreement is that every five years a study be conducted to evaluate whether available resources will be able to meet forecasted water demands. The seventh in the series of such studies has just been released.  This time the ICPRB found that if droughts become much more severe as predicted in the climate forecast, even with the addition of the Vulcan Quarry, Milston Quarry, Travilah Quarry and Luck Stone Quarry B as reservoirs (adding over 13 billion gallons of water storage) and using water restrictions and demand management the WMA water supply may be unable to meet combined water supply needs and the environmental flow-by at Little Falls. In other words according to the forecast by 2050 we run out of water for periods under more than one third of the forecast scenarios. It is to be noted that without the addition of the 7.8 billion gallon Travilah Quarry as additional storage the WMA water systems experience failures by 2040 in the forecasts.

The new ICPRB study forecasts of water demands for the WMA through, 2050, taking into account projected demographic and societal changes that may affect future water use,  forecasts of water availability, considering the potential impact of changes in climate and upstream water use on system resources, and  an evaluation of the ability of current and planned system resources to meet the forecasted demands. Using various scenarios the  current study also assesses the effectiveness of several options for enhancing the current regional water supply system that were recommended in a special study conducted in 2017 (Schultz et al., 2017). This special study evaluated and compared the ability of 10 proposed changes and additions to the WMA water supply system to meet the challenges of growing regional demand for water with a supply that does not grow and the potential impacts of climate change when the region expects to have more intense wet years and longer droughts.

The Potomac River supplies, on average, just over three quarters of the WMA’s surface water needs. The rest of the water supply comes from Occoquan River, the Patuxent River and regional groundwater supplies an estimated 27% of end use demand. The Co-Op members provided the funding for three upstream reservoirs: Jennings Randolph, Little Seneca, and Savage. Water in these reservoirs is released during drought to augment natural river flow. In addition, Fairfax Water and WSSC Water rely daily on reservoirs outside of the drainage area of the Potomac River, on the Occoquan River (7.85 billion gallons) and the Patuxent River (10.4 billion gallons), respectively. Two additional reservoirs are planned to be in place within the next 20 years: Loudoun Water’s Milestone Reservoir(1.25 billion gallons)  , scheduled for completion in 2024, and Fairfax Water’s Vulcan Quarry Phase 1 (1.7 billion gallons), planned to be in place by 2040 to augment their Occoquan supply.

Due to continuing improvements in efficiencies of household water fixtures and appliances and consumer behavior, water use in the WMA has remained remarkably steady for almost three decades despite continuing population growth. Water demand averaged 453 million gallons per day (MGD) for the CO-OP suppliers during the most recent period for which data is available (2014-2018). This does not count the water use from groundwater nor the water use by smaller water supply utilities that have their own water supply. Forecasts of average annual water demand were developed using average per person and household use and a forecast that population in the WMA in 2050 will be 6.1 million, a 27% increase from 2018 levels. The ICPRB projects that average annual  water demand will increase to 501 MGD (10%) by 2040 and to 528 MGD (16%) by 2050. The estimated uncertainties (one standard error) in 2040 and 2050 are ±9.7% and ±10.4%, respectively.

While the demand for water increases, the climate projections indicate that the mid-Atlantic states, on average, are becoming and will continue to get “wetter.” Climate scientists also warn; however,  that extreme conditions, that is, floods and droughts, will become more severe.  Our water infrastructure will have to include more water storage to meet a larger demand during longer droughts.

The ICPRB used nine scenarios to represent ranges of uncertainties in the impact of climate change on water availability in the Potomac basin and in future WMA water demand. For each scenario, Potomac Reservoir and River Simulation Model (PRRISM) simulations were done in  four different configurations of the WMA system: a system with current and planned resources, and a system that has been enhanced with  operation controls using water restrictions,  the current system with operating controls and the Travilah Quarry and finally the current system with operation controls the Travilah Quarry and Luck Stone Quarry B added storage.

On average, precipitation in the Potomac River watershed in 2040 and 2050 is projected to increase by 8% and 10%, respectively, and temperature is projected to increase by 2.16 °C (3.9 °F) and 2.5 °C (4.5 °F), respectively. There is tremendous uncertainty about how climate change will affect streamflows. This study relies on a simple climate response function, based on a least squares multiple regression analysis, to predict mean annual natural Potomac River flow from mean annual precipitation, mean annual temperature, and the previous year’s mean flow.

Four summary statistics are used as key performance metrics are listed in the colored boxes below:

  • Percent years with no Potomac flow deficits: the percentage of years in the simulation period in which flow in the Potomac River at Little Falls is above 100 MGD (the Little Falls flow-by) on every day of the year, that is, in which combined WMA Potomac water supply needs and the environmental flow-by at Little Falls is always met.
  • Percent years with emergency restrictions: the percentage of years over the simulation period in which emergency water use restrictions are implemented on one or more days of the year. In this study, emergency restrictions are assumed to be implemented when combined water supply storage in Jennings Randolph and Little Seneca reservoirs is below 5% of the combined capacity.
  • Maximum 1-day Potomac flow deficit (MGD): the maximum shortfall in meeting combined WMA Potomac water supply needs and the Little Falls environmental flow-by on any single day of the simulation period.
  • Minimum Travilah Quarry storage (BG): the minimum storage in Travilah experienced over the course of the simulation period.

The last statistic, minimum Travilah Quarry storage, is of interest because of the dual role that Travilah is expected to play in the WMA water supply system: as a backup supply in case of an emergency spill and as a resource to mitigate drought. Reductions in Travilah storage during drought reduce or eliminate this reservoir’s ability to serve as a backup supply in case of a spill. Results of the study indicate that if droughts become much more severe as climate models forecast, the WMA system may be unable to meet combined water supply needs and the environmental flow-by at Little Falls even if all of the recommended options of the 2017 alternatives study are implemented, including Travilah Quarry and Luck Stone Quarry B. 


The Charts show: Percent years with no Potomac River deficits, Percent years with emergency restrictions, Maximum 1-day Potomac River flow deficit, Minimum Travilah Quarry storage top to bottom in each box.

No comments:

Post a Comment